Notion for Novel Planning vs Story Bible Studio: An Honest Comparison

Notion for novel planning gives you a blank canvas; Story Bible Studio gives you a ready-made story bible. Here is an honest look at which suits you.

Bonus: Download the free Story Bible Starter Kit and plan your story section by section as you read.

Notion has become a favourite with novelists who like to build their own systems. Open a blank page, add a database of characters, link it to a table of scenes, and you have a planning tool shaped exactly the way your brain works. Story Bible Studio comes at the same job from the other side: the structure is already there, built for fiction, and you fill it in.

So which should you use? Full disclosure: Story Bible Studio is our own tool, so I have tried to be fair to both. Here is an honest comparison of Notion for novel planning and Story Bible Studio, and who each one suits.

Notion for Novel Planning vs Story Bible Studio at a Glance

Notion Story Bible Studio
What it is An all-in-one workspace for notes, wikis and databases An online story bible and planning space for fiction writers
Setting up Build your own system, or adapt a template Guided sections for characters, places, plot and world, ready to fill in
Linking story elements Database relations you set up yourself Links between characters, places and plot built in
Drafting Possible in a page, but not built as a manuscript tool Manuscript space, sprint timer and word tracker beside your story bible
Working with others Share pages and edit together Groups for writing circles, classes and co-authors, with word-count challenges
Price Free plan for individuals, with paid plans Free account, with a paid Writer's Studio subscription

Where Notion Shines

Notion for novel planning: a desk with notes, phone and laptop

Photo: JESHOOTS.COM on Unsplash

Notion's great strength is freedom. Everything is built from blocks: text, headings, checklists, images, toggles and databases. For novel planning, the databases are the clever part. You can make a characters database, a scenes database and a locations database, then link them with relations, so each scene shows who is in it and where it happens.

The same data can be shown in different views: a table for detail, a board for scenes by act or status, a timeline for events, a gallery for character cards. If you love seeing your story from several angles, that is hard to beat.

Notion is also good at everything around the novel: research notes, a submissions tracker, a reading list, newsletter plans. If you already run your life in Notion, keeping your book there too has real appeal, and there are plenty of community templates for novel planning to get you started.

Story Bible Studio - digital space for writers to plot, plan, and build better stories.

Start yours today.

Where Notion Gets in the Way

That freedom has a price. Notion doesn't know what a novel is. You decide what a character entry contains, how scenes link to chapters and how you track the timeline. Writers who enjoy building systems love that. Writers who just want to plan their book can lose whole weekends designing databases instead of writing.

Templates help, but somebody else's template carries somebody else's thinking, and most Notion novelists end up tweaking and rebuilding. That's fine if tinkering relaxes you. It's a trap if it becomes a way to avoid the hard work of the story. And because Notion is a general tool, drafting a long manuscript, tracking word counts and running writing sprints usually mean workarounds or other apps.

Where Story Bible Studio Shines

A notebook resting on a laptop

Photo: Fiona Murray-deGraaff on Unsplash

Story Bible Studio is built for one job: keeping the facts of your story in one place while you write it. When you start a project, the sections are already there for characters, places, plot and world, with prompts that nudge you to think about motives, conflicts and arcs. You don't design anything. You start filling in your story.

Characters, places and plot points can be linked, so you can see who belongs where and which scenes involve whom. The manuscript space, sprint timer and word tracker sit beside your story bible, so you can check a character's eye colour without leaving the chapter you're writing.

Groups let a writing circle, a class or co-authors work together, with word-count challenges and a leaderboard. That's how we run the Samhain Story Sprint this November.

Where Story Bible Studio Falls Short

Structure suits some writers more than others. If you like to invent your own fields and views for everything, the guided sections may feel tidy rather than freeing. Story Bible Studio is an online app, so you need an internet connection. It isn't trying to be a second brain for your whole life either: research archives, project management and personal notes belong elsewhere. And while you can start free, the fuller Writer's Studio plan is a subscription.

Which One Should You Choose?

Choose Notion if you enjoy building systems, already use Notion for everything, want many custom views of your data, or plan your book alongside lots of non-writing projects.

Choose Story Bible Studio if you want to start planning today without designing anything, you'd rather have prompts than a blank page, you want your story bible next to your draft, or you write with a group.

Plenty of writers use both: Notion for life admin and research, Story Bible Studio for the book itself. And if you're not sure your idea is ready for either, start with a strong premise. My three tips for crafting a premise will help, and if you're still deciding whether a story bible is worth the effort, read why a story bible made me a believer.

Final Thoughts on Notion for Novel Planning

Notion for novel planning is a superb blank canvas for writers who like to build. Story Bible Studio is a ready-made home for your story, for writers who'd rather get on with writing. Neither is wrong. The best tool is the one you will actually open tomorrow morning. Try both free with your current project, plan one chapter in each, and see which makes you want to keep going.

Ready to try the ready-made route? Story Bible Studio keeps your characters, places, plot notes and draft in one place. Want to practise with other writers? Try a round of collaborative fiction on Chain Story Online, and find more ideas for readers and writers on Enda Storrie.

Story Bible Studio

Build it in Story Bible Studio: skip the database design and start with characters, places and plot sections that are already built for fiction. Create your free Story Bible Studio account, then grab the free Story Bible Starter Kit to fill it in section by section.

Still comparing tools? See what Story Bible Studio can do for your novel.

Related reading: Scrivener vs Story Bible Studio: Which Novel Planner Fits You? · Best Novel Outlining Software for Plotters

That's it. Enda Storrie

P.S. Planning a story? Grab the free Story Bible Starter Kit: 8 fillable pages for your characters, places and timeline.